Reading Material On Order

10 06 2010

June 10, 2010 (Updated May 29, 2011)

I must admit that I am a bit surprised by the number of page views for the “Oracle SQL Recipes: A Problem – Solution Approach” book review that I posted 4 days ago.  That article is currently in 12th place for the number of page views on this blog in the last 90 days, and currently has half as many page views as the blog article in first place for the last 90 days (there are currently 202 blog articles on this blog).  You may have noticed that, unlike my other blog articles, I do not permit readers to post comments on blog articles that are book reviews.  I personally pay for each book that I review, and I try to post reviews of books with that criteria in mind – am I getting my money’s worth from the book, and what do I think about the book’s contents.

I missed the first 10 minutes of the Ultimate SQL Query Tune Off webinar today – the client-side version of the Live Meeting software kept crashing, simply stating that a problem happened, see your administrator.  The webinar started off with a roughly 50 minute long presentation by Jonathan Lewis.  Later, there were a lot of great questions asked after the formal portion of the webinar, and I am a bit surprised just how quickly extremely detailed (and more importantly correct) answers were provided for the questions.  Interestingly, some of the issues that I raised (or were related) about the Oracle SQL Recipes book were also asked as questions (I am sure that it was purely coincidental, but still interesting):

  • Why isn’t my index being used.
  • Is there any certain way to know if it is safe to drop an index (monitoring is not sufficient).
  • Rebuilding indexes and Metalink notes.

The question of what books should be read was also asked.  I have previously posted my recommendations for books.  As of Monday I had three new books on Order:


The first book was supposed to be in stock on June 1, but I received an email stating that Amazon is still trying to locate that book. I ordered that book simply because I was curious. I had bumped into that book’s author several times on Oracle’s OTN forums, usually with interesting results. Any book offered with the following warning must be interesting:

“This is not a book for beginners. Targeted at the senior Oracle DBA, this comprehensive book gives you all of the knowledge you need to be successful in tuning even the most complex Oracle database.”

I ordered the second book because I had previously purchased two copies of the 9i/10g edition of this book, and I purchased his “Expert One On One” book.

I ordered the third book because I had previously purchased that author’s “Forecasting Oracle Performance” book. The “Oracle Performance Firefighting” book (fourth printing) arrived by email on Tuesday. I am a bit disappointed that I cannot print the PDF file, nor copy sections of the PDF file – something that is permitted in the PDF copy of the “Expert Oracle Practices” book that I bought from Apress. I am also a bit surprised that my name, address, and phone number appear at the top of every page of the “Oracle Performance Firefighting” book, but I understand why. I am roughly 20 pages into the book, but it has not yet latched onto my undivided attention as has happened with some of the other books.

I plan to post detailed reviews of these three book, just as I did with the “Oracle SQL Recipes” book.

—————-
(Added May 5, 2011)
Reviews of the above books:
Oracle Tuning: The Definitive Reference Second Edition
Expert Oracle Database Architecture: Oracle Database Programming 9i, 10g, and 11g Techniques and Solutions, Second Edition
Oracle Performance Firefighting
—————-

On a related note, some people (myself included) have spent a significant amount of time and effort creating content that is posted in blogs, Usenet/OTN forums, various websites, and in some cases books. I posted the following today, somewhere:

You have a fundamental misunderstanding of U.S. Copyright law (I understand that you reside in the United States based on your profiles):
http://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ1.pdf

Copyright ownership is immediate, and does not need to be registered for entitlement.

It is absolutely not the responsibility of people to tell you not to post their work. It is your responsibility to obtain the permission of the copyright holder to post material that is owned by the copyright holders, whether it is pictures, large sections of text, or scripts.

Fair use laws do allow you, in some cases, to reproduce small sections of copyright work, but you must cite where the original material is found:
http://www.copyright.gov/fls/fl102.html

Consider this – you have spent tens of hours, hundreds of hours, or thousands of hours to produce something in written form, a book for instance. You have carefully specified every word on the page to state exactly what needs to be stated to clearly communicate a concept. You have spent hours building and testing scripts, verifying the results across different Oracle releases and different hardware platforms. A technical reviewer and an editor have reviewed your work, and you have made significant modifications to that work to more clearly communicate concepts that cannot be found through other resources. You assemble the scripts into an easily used format, and then you publish your work.

Now, someone finds all of your hard work, thinks it looks impressive, runs your test scripts through their system, captures a bit of the output, changes a couple words in the text, and then publishes the material (possibly for profit) as their own hard work. By reproducing the hard work of others and publishing it as their own original content, they are robbing the original producers of that content, not only of their entitlement under copyright law, but also of all of their hard work and potential monetary benefit that may be derived from that work.

That is exactly what you are doing by posting the original works of others with just a couple of changed words.

Kind of odd that I would post that message, or maybe not. For the record, it was not my material that was copied without attribution.


Actions

Information

4 responses

10 06 2010
11 06 2010
Charles Hooper

Joel,

On first sight of your link I could not understand why the newspaper people would go after the cat people, but after reading all three pages of the article, I see how the article relates to the part of this article that begins with “On a related note…”

11 06 2010
David Mann

Charles if they don’t find your copy of Oracle Tuning: The Definitive Reference shortly cancel the order let me know and I will send you mine if you cover shipping. I won it at a conference so consider it a Community Contribution :)

11 06 2010
Charles Hooper

David,

I appreciate the offer.

However, just a couple of minor problems:
* I will not be able to tell if I am getting my money’s worth from the book if I receive the book for free, so I might have difficulty assembling a review that is as in-depth as my other reviews.
* I could write a 4 page review on the first 27 pages of the first edition of the book (based on a Google preview of the first edition), even with the larger than typical font size that seems to appear in some books. I ordered the second edition of the book, hoping that many of the issues that have been mentioned to the author regarding the first edition of the book are corrected. I certainly hope that I do not see waits on the CPU in the second edition of the book – I mentioned this to the author in an OTN thread in October 2009 (thread is linked in my book recommendations article).
* I want to see a comprehensive book that gives me all of the knowledge that I need to troubleshoot any system – if it reads like a 1,000 page true or false test I will be disappointed.
* It will be interesting to see which of the two books still on order ships first.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 144 other followers

%d bloggers like this: